Get ready for an exciting journey into the world of fantasy baseball! We're about to uncover some hidden gems at the 2B and SS positions that could be your secret weapons for the 2026 season. But here's the catch: these players are often overlooked, and their potential is underestimated. So, let's dive in and explore why these sleepers deserve a spot on your fantasy team!
Our expert panel, including Eno Sarris, Derek VanRiper, and Andy Behrens, has carefully selected these middle infielders who are poised to make a significant impact. With a scarcity of top-tier options, this group could be the key to your fantasy success.
The Middle Infield Sleepers:
Ozzie Albies, Atlanta Braves: Albies is a prime example of a player who deserves a second look. Just two years ago, he finished among the top 15 fantasy players. With a daily spot in the Braves' lineup, Albies brings an impressive approach and base-stealing skills. His projections match those of Mookie Betts, yet he's being drafted much later. Get ready for a 20/20 season from Albies!
Ezequiel Tovar, Colorado Rockies: Tovar had a tough 2025, but don't let that fool you. He was once the 11th most valuable fantasy middle infielder at just 22 years old. Tovar's defensive skills keep him in the lineup, and Coors Field is his cheat code. Our experts predict a bounce-back season, with Tovar ranked as the 15th best shortstop and 4th best second baseman in fantasy.
Luis Garcia, Washington Nationals: Garcia might not be a household name, but he's a valuable asset for your fantasy team. With a solid 18/22 season under his belt, Garcia can provide respectable power and speed. He's still young at 25, and his average is a solid .280+. Don't miss out on this underrated player!
JJ Wetherholt, St. Louis Cardinals: The Cardinals' rookie is flying under the radar, but our experts see his potential. Wetherholt dominated at Double and Triple-A last season, and his advanced hitting skills remind us of Corbin Carroll. With the departure of key players, Wetherholt has a chance to shine. Draft him now, and you might just have the Rookie of the Year on your team!
Colson Montgomery, Chicago White Sox: Montgomery is a power-hitting sensation. In his first MLB season, he slugged 21 homers, and his bat speed is top-notch. At just 23, there's room for improvement, and with more plate appearances, he could reach 35 homers. Don't let the batting average scare you; Montgomery is a Taylor Ward/Jo Adell-like talent at a much later draft pick.
Jorge Polanco, New York Mets: Polanco is a Statcast standout. He's one of only 17 hitters to make the cut in five key categories. With a reduced strikeout rate and an OPS+ above average, Polanco is a consistent run producer. Batting cleanup for the Mets, he's poised to drive in 100+ runs.
Andres Gimenez, Toronto Blue Jays: Gimenez is a veteran with a fresh start. His price has dropped, but his talent remains. He could be a steal for your deep league middle infield slot. If he hits his peak, you might see 15 homers and 30 steals. Don't underestimate this experienced player!
Willi Castro, Colorado Rockies: Castro's Statcast page might not be flashy, but he's a consistent performer. He's generated positive value for Roto leagues in the past. With a new home in Colorado, Castro could thrive at Coors Field. Expect an improved batting average and his first 15-15 season.
Remember, these players are often overlooked, but their potential is immense. Don't miss out on these fantasy baseball sleepers! And this is the part most people miss: the middle infield is crucial, and these players could be the difference-makers.
What do you think? Are you ready to draft these sleepers and dominate your fantasy league? Let's discuss in the comments and share your thoughts on these hidden gems!
